Theatregold Musical   ·  Show History & Every Major Production

Tootsie the Musical: The Complete History, From Dustin Hoffman’s Film to Broadway’s Funniest New Musical

Few Broadway musicals have had a more unusual journey to the stage than Tootsie — a show built on a 40-year-old idea about a struggling actor who disguises himself as a woman to land a job, reworked for an era when that premise itself had become a minefield. What emerged in 2019 was, depending on who you ask, either one of the smartest backstage comedies Broadway had seen in years or a relic that hadn’t quite caught up with the cultural moment it opened into. It won two Tony Awards, closed at a loss less than a year later, and has quietly kept touring, licensing, and translating itself around the world ever since. Here’s the full story — the 1982 film that started it all, the decade-long road to Broadway, the reviews, the awards, the casts, and everywhere Tootsie has played since.

1982 Original Film Release

2019 Broadway Opening

11 Tony Nominations

2 Tony Wins

318 Broadway Performances

6+ Countries Produced

From Screen to Stage: The 1982 Film That Started It All

Before it was a musical, Tootsie was one of the defining comedies of the 1980s. Directed by Sydney Pollack from a screenplay credited to Larry Gelbart and Murray Schisgal (based on a story by Gelbart and Don McGuire), the 1982 film starred Dustin Hoffman as Michael Dorsey, a talented but professionally impossible New York actor who — unable to get hired anywhere — reinvents himself as the actress “Dorothy Michaels” to land a role on a daytime soap opera. The film also starred Jessica Lange, Teri Garr, Dabney Coleman, Charles Durning, and, in her screen debut, Geena Davis, with Bill Murray in an uncredited supporting turn as Michael’s roommate Jeff.

The road to the screen was almost as tangled as the plot itself. The project began life as an early-1970s play by Don McGuire, and by the time it reached Hoffman, it had already passed through several screenwriters and at least two attached directors, Hal Ashby and Dick Richards, before Pollack came aboard. Hoffman — fresh off his Oscar win for Kramer vs. Kramer — took the project to playwright Murray Schisgal and insisted on full creative control, eventually bringing in Larry Gelbart (the creator of M*A*S*H) to co-write the script. Uncredited contributions came from several other writers, including Elaine May, who reportedly took a flat $450,000 fee for three weeks of work adding a woman’s perspective to the screenplay rather than accept a formal credit.

The title itself was Hoffman’s idea, taken from his mother’s pet name for him as a child — “How’s my Tootsie Wootsie?” To make Dorothy convincing, Hoffman trained for months with drag performer Holly Woodlawn and actress Polly Holliday, worked with a dialect coach to develop Dorothy’s Southern-accented voice, and endured daily makeup and prosthetic sessions so extensive that he could only film as Dorothy for three or four hours before his beard grew back through the makeup. He later said the experience — realizing he found “Dorothy” plain rather than beautiful, and that he’d have ignored her at a party — changed how he thought about the entire project, turning it from a comedy into what he considered a piece of genuine social commentary.

Released by Columbia Pictures on December 17, 1982, Tootsie was an immediate sensation, grossing $177.2 million worldwide and becoming the third-highest-grossing film of that year. It earned ten Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, Best Director, and a Best Actor nod for Hoffman, but won only one: Best Supporting Actress for Jessica Lange (who was simultaneously up for Best Actress that year for a different film, Frances). In 1998, the Library of Congress selected Tootsie for preservation in the National Film Registry as a work of lasting cultural significance — cementing its status as one of American cinema’s most enduring comedies, decades before anyone thought to put it on a Broadway stage.

Adapting a 1982 Comedy for a Different Era

Turning Tootsie into a stage musical meant confronting a problem that didn’t exist in 1982: a premise built on a man disguising himself as a woman lands very differently in an era of far greater public understanding of gender identity. Book writer Robert Horn and composer-lyricist David Yazbek — who had just won the 2018 Tony Award for Best Original Score for The Band’s Visit — made one significant structural change to try to defuse some of that tension: rather than a daytime soap opera, the musical’s “show within the show” became a splashy, doomed Broadway musical called Juliet’s Nurse, turning the entire project into an affectionate, joke-heavy send-up of Broadway itself — its auditions, its backstage politics, its producers, and its overwrought choreography.

The musical had its first industry reading in June 2017, with Tony winner Casey Nicholaw (The Book of Mormon, Some Like It Hot) initially attached to direct. By the time the show moved toward its full Chicago tryout, Nicholaw had been replaced by Scott Ellis, a veteran Broadway and television director whose credits include She Loves Me and 1776. Santino Fontana — a Tony nominee for Cinderella and best known to television audiences as the voice of Prince Hans in Disney’s Frozen and as Greg on The CW’s Crazy Ex-Girlfriend — was cast in the dual role of Michael Dorsey and Dorothy Michaels from these earliest stages of development.

Robert Horn came to the project as a veteran television writer-producer (Emmy-winning work on Designing Women and Living Single among his credits) who had only recently pivoted toward the stage; he would go on, several years after Tootsie, to write the Tony-winning book for Shucked, a musical comedy that shares more than a little of Tootsie‘s appetite for rapid-fire wordplay and structural self-awareness about musical theatre conventions. That throughline — a writer fascinated by the mechanics and absurdities of putting on a show — helps explain why Tootsie‘s backstage-musical framing felt like such a natural fit for the material, even when critics disagreed about how well the broader premise had aged.

World Premiere: Chicago, September 2018

Tootsie had its world-premiere tryout at Chicago’s Cadillac Palace Theatre, beginning previews September 11, 2018, officially opening September 30, and running through October 14. The Chicago production already featured most of what would become the Broadway company: Fontana as Michael/Dorothy, Lilli Cooper as leading lady Julie Nichols, Sarah Stiles as Michael’s neurotic ex-girlfriend Sandy Lester, John Behlmann as vain reality-TV himbo Max Van Horn, Andy Grotelueschen as roommate Jeff Slater, Julie Halston as producer Rita Marshall, Michael McGrath as agent Stan Fields, and Reg Rogers as blustering director Ron Carlisle.

Chicago Tribune critic Chris Jones praised the tryout for “getting many things right” and singled out Fontana’s performance as a major asset heading into Broadway, while offering notes on where the show still needed work. Michael Phillips, also writing for the Tribune, was more circumspect about the difficulty of translating an early-1980s film premise to the stage “especially in an era of more gender fluidity,” though he noted reviews at the time ranged from “so-so to very good” and that “opening night laughs were plentiful.” Even at this early stage, the production drew criticism from transgender and non-binary commentators and writers, who argued the show’s entire comedic engine — a cisgender man’s disguise played for repeated “man in a dress” laughs — sat uncomfortably against the community’s own lived experience, regardless of whether the show intended harm.

Broadway Opens: April 23, 2019

After a substantial round of rewrites following Chicago, Tootsie began previews at the Marquis Theatre on March 29, 2019, and officially opened on April 23. The Broadway creative team carried over nearly intact from Chicago: direction by Scott Ellis, choreography by Denis Jones, scenic design by David Rockwell, costumes by William Ivey Long, lighting by Donald Holder, sound by Brian Ronan, orchestrations by Simon Hale, and music supervision by Andrea Grody and Dean Sharenow.

Reviews were, on balance, strong — The New York Times named it a Critic’s Pick, The New York Post called it “Broadway’s funniest new musical,” Forbes called it “the best comedy on Broadway,” and Rolling Stone’s review declared Fontana’s performance “one of the best in musical comedy history.” Variety’s Frank Rizzo praised the production’s craftsmanship — Long’s costumes, Jones’s choreography, Ellis’s unsparing satirical direction — while noting the tension inherent in Yazbek’s cleverest lyrics occasionally outrunning the melodies meant to carry them. The show earned the New York Drama Critics’ Circle Award for Best Musical that spring, an early sign of the industry goodwill it would carry into Tony season.

The plot, updated for the stage, follows Michael Dorsey — fired from a production for arguing with its director, Ron Carlisle, over a “logical” objection during a commercial shoot — as he spirals through his fortieth birthday realizing how little he’s accomplished professionally. Roommate Jeff Slater, an unproduced playwright, reads Michael the bucket list he wrote at nineteen; ex-girlfriend Sandy Lester, auditioning for the ill-fated musical Juliet’s Nurse, unwittingly gives Michael the idea to audition in her place — in drag — when he can’t get past a room full of casting directors as himself. He’s cast as “Dorothy Michaels,” becomes an overnight Broadway sensation, and falls for his co-star Julie Nichols, all while racing to keep his disguise from unraveling before opening night. The unmasking, when it finally comes during the show-within-the-show’s finale number “Arrivederci!”, plays out publicly on stage in front of the entire company — a structural choice that gives the musical’s version of the reveal considerably higher stakes than the film’s more private unmasking.

Tony Night: A Two-Award Haul from Eleven Nominations

Tootsie arrived at the 2019 Tony Awards with eleven nominations — tied for the most of any show that season — including Best Musical, Best Book of a Musical (Robert Horn), Best Original Score (David Yazbek), Best Direction of a Musical (Scott Ellis), Best Choreography (Denis Jones), Best Leading Actor in a Musical (Santino Fontana), Best Featured Actor in a Musical (Andy Grotelueschen), Best Featured Actress in a Musical (both Lilli Cooper and Sarah Stiles were nominated), and Best Costume Design (William Ivey Long).

On the night, Tootsie won two: Best Book of a Musical for Robert Horn, and Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Musical for Santino Fontana — beating out a field that included Hadestown’s own eventual Best Musical winner sweep elsewhere in the ceremony. The show also picked up strong recognition from the season’s other honoring bodies, including Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle nominations across nearly every major category, and the Drama League’s Distinguished Performance Award for Fontana specifically.

A Complicated Commercial Story

For all its critical and awards-season success, Tootsie never became the commercial hit its pedigree suggested it should be. Capitalized at roughly $20 million — a substantial sum for an original musical comedy without pre-existing music catalogue behind it — the show struggled to build the sustained word-of-mouth needed to fill the Marquis Theatre week after week. By November 2019, with the production running at around 70 percent capacity and cumulative Broadway grosses of roughly $31.2 million over 33 weeks, producers announced the show would play its final Broadway performance on January 5, 2020.

The show closed having played 293 regular performances and 25 previews — a run of just over nine months from its April opening. Trade coverage at the time noted that while the traditionally lucrative holiday season might help producers claw back some of their investment, Tootsie seemed all but certain to close in the red, a stark contrast with genuine box-office recoupment success stories from the same Broadway season, such as Hadestown, which had announced it had already recouped its investment that same November.

Great Casts: The Performers Who Brought Tootsie to Life

Whatever the show’s commercial fate, Tootsie‘s Broadway company was, almost without exception, singled out by critics — several performances here rank among the most acclaimed of the performers’ careers.

The Score: David Yazbek’s Backstage Songbook

David Yazbek came to Tootsie as one of Broadway’s most consistently inventive composer-lyricists, having already scored The Full Monty, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown, and, most recently before Tootsie, the Tony-winning The Band’s Visit. Where that score was hushed and atmospheric, Tootsie gave Yazbek license to write in a completely different register: brassy, joke-dense, up-tempo musical-comedy numbers built for maximum laugh density rather than subtlety.

The score’s most celebrated numbers tend to be its patter songs — pieces built less around melody than around the sheer density and speed of their internal rhyme schemes. Sarah Stiles’s opening number “What’s Gonna Happen” set the tone immediately, a breathless, anxiety-spiraling solo that critics repeatedly cited as a technical high-wire act. Andy Grotelueschen’s “Jeff Sums It Up” performed a similar trick in the second act, using rapid-fire lyrics to recap the entire plot’s accumulating farce in real time. Fontana’s Act One anthem “I Won’t Let You Down” — Dorothy’s triumphant response to landing the lead in Juliet’s Nurse — became the closest thing the show had to a soaring, traditional-musical-comedy showstopper, staged with lighting design from Donald Holder that critics described as building to a deliberately, hilariously overheated climax. Lilli Cooper’s “There Was John,” meanwhile, provided the score’s most sincere moment, a ballad giving Julie’s character genuine emotional interiority amid the surrounding farce.

Reviewers were consistently more enthusiastic about Yazbek’s lyrics than about the music built to carry them — Variety’s review noted that the sheer cleverness of some couplets occasionally outpaced the melodies underneath, a criticism that echoed across several outlets without ever seriously denting the show’s overall Best Original Score Tony nomination. The original Broadway cast recording, released in 2019, remains the definitive document of that score and continues to find listeners well beyond the show’s brief Broadway run — one more piece of Tootsie‘s afterlife that has outlasted its commercial run at the Marquis.

Life After Broadway: The First National Tour

Even before the Broadway production announced its closing, plans were underway for a life beyond the Marquis Theatre. Music Theatre International acquired the show’s worldwide licensing rights in May 2019, just weeks after opening, and a Non-Equity First National Tour was announced for 2020 — ultimately delayed by the COVID-19 pandemic and launching October 10, 2021, at Shea’s Performing Arts Center in Buffalo, New York.

The tour was led by Drew Becker as Michael Dorsey/Dorothy Michaels, alongside Ashley Alexandra as Julie Nichols, Payton Reilly as Sandy Lester, Lukas James Miller as Max Van Horn, Jared David Michael Grant as Jeff Slater, Kathy Halenda as Rita Marshall, Steve Brustien as Stan Fields, and Adam du Plessis as Ron Carlisle, directed by Dave Solomon (recreating Scott Ellis’s original Broadway direction) with Denis Jones’s choreography restaged for the road. Reviewing the tour’s Washington, D.C. engagement at the National Theatre, DC Theater Arts called the production “a triumph,” praising Becker’s performance and singling out Reilly’s “dizzyingly difficult” delivery of “What’s Gonna Happen” for particular praise. The tour went on to play regional and touring houses across North America for several seasons, and the show has since become a fixture of the regional and summer-stock circuit, including a 2024 production at North Shore Music Theatre in Massachusetts.

Around the World: Tootsie’s International Life

Producers announced an ambitious slate of international productions alongside the North American tour — a West End transfer targeted for 2021, plus productions across Australia and New Zealand (which would also tour to Singapore, Thailand, Hong Kong, and Taiwan), and a Japanese-language production in Tokyo. The pandemic scrambled most of that timeline: the West End production, despite years of “coming soon” listings on London ticketing sites, has yet to materialize, with venue and casting still unconfirmed as of this writing — making Tootsie one of a number of pre-2020 Broadway transfers whose London plans never quite recovered their momentum.

Internationally, the show has had more concrete success outside the English-speaking world. A Spanish-language production officially opened October 22, 2025, at the Teatre Apolo in Barcelona, Spain, bringing Horn and Yazbek’s backstage farce to a new audience in translation — a notable milestone for a show whose Broadway commercial fortunes never matched its critical and awards-season reception, and a reminder that a musical’s financial story on Broadway is rarely the end of its life as a piece of theatre.

The Debate: Comedy in a Changing Cultural Moment

No account of Tootsie‘s history is complete without acknowledging the critical debate that followed the show from its Chicago tryout through its Broadway run and beyond. Writing in American Theatre, critic Christian Lewis argued that despite containing no transgender characters, the musical’s comedy repeatedly used trans people as an implicit punchline, built as it was around an extended “man in a dress” premise that some critics and advocates characterized as rooted in transmisogyny, regardless of the creative team’s intentions. Robert Horn and David Yazbek’s decision to shift the show’s target of satire from the source film’s soap-opera industry to Broadway itself was, in part, a response to exactly this tension — an attempt to make the show’s comedy about the theatre business and Michael’s own dishonesty rather than about gender itself. Critical opinion remained split on how successfully that shift worked in practice, and the debate is very much part of the show’s documented history alongside its reviews and award nominations.

Legacy: A Love Letter to Theatre That Keeps Finding New Audiences

More than four decades after Dustin Hoffman first pulled on a pair of heels for a movie he didn’t originally intend as comedy, Tootsie‘s stage afterlife tells a familiar Broadway story: a show that never recouped its investment in New York but has continued to generate income and find audiences through touring, regional licensing, and international translation ever since. The original cast recording remains in print and streaming, MTI’s licensing arrangement has brought the show to community, high school, and regional stages across the country, and its 2025 Barcelona premiere suggests its international life is still, in some ways, just beginning.

For a musical built entirely around the tension between what an actor is willing to do for a role and what it costs the people around him, Tootsie‘s own commercial history feels almost thematically appropriate — a show about desperate reinvention that has, in its own way, had to reinvent itself continuously since 2019 to keep finding its footing. Whether remembered primarily as a showcase for one of the great dual performances in recent Broadway history, or as a case study in how much harder it is to adapt beloved 1980s comedy for a more culturally attuned era, Tootsie remains, as its own marketing insisted from Chicago onward, unmistakably a love letter to the theatre that made it — warts, wig, and all.

 

---

Sources: Playbill, Broadway.com, BroadwayWorld, Variety, The Hollywood Reporter, IBDB, Music Theatre International, Wikipedia, DC Theater Arts, TCM, Criterion Collection, London Theatreland.

Tags: Tootsie the musical  Tootsie Broadway  Santino Fontana Tootsie  David Yazbek musical  Robert Horn Tootsie  Tootsie 1982 film  Tootsie national tour  Tootsie musical cast  Tootsie Tony Awards  Dustin Hoffman Tootsie