Top 10 Broadway Shows of 2026: Critics’ Ranking, From Hamilton to Downstate
|
Theatregold · Broadway Ranked
Top 10 Broadway Productions of 2026Eleven years of Hamilton, a Pulitzer winner’s hard-hitting drama, a drag-clown comedy about Mary Todd Lincoln and a Christmas classic with a foley artist: what the critics rate on Broadway this year.
Critics’ Consensus Guide · Updated November 21, 2026
|
Broadway in 2026 is a story of staying power. The show at the top of the critics’ chart opened in 2015, and the two next to it opened in 2011 and 2024. Alongside them sit a Disney juggernaut that has played the Minskoff since 1997, a revival of Kander and Ebb that has been at the Ambassador since 2003, and two openings from this very month. Broadway Scorecard’s “Top 10 Highest Rated Broadway Shows (2026)” page, last updated this month, ranks every show currently running by a weighted critic score and lists audience grades alongside it. We kept that order and then checked each entry against Playbill, TheaterMania, BroadwayWorld, Broadway.com, Broadway News, New York Theatre Guide, IBDB and the productions’ own announcements for venues, casts, awards, box office and booking dates.
How We Ranked Them
This is a consensus guide, not a personal list. Broadway Scorecard’s CriticScore is a weighted average of professional reviews in which The New York Times, Vulture and Variety count for more than other outlets. A letter grade for audiences is shown separately, and we have reproduced both. We kept the site’s order, including ties; all ten shows are running in 2026.
Two things are worth knowing before you read on. First, the old shows are judged by old reviews. Broadway Scorecard notes that most of Hamilton’s reviews date from 2015, The Book of Mormon’s from 2011 and The Lion King’s from 1997, so those scores reflect the critics’ first impressions and the shows’ subsequent reputations rather than fresh reappraisals. Second, the tenth show is a special case. It’s A Wonderful Life opened on November 18, and Broadway Scorecard counts just one review so far, so it appears on the list without a score. We treat it as a promising newcomer rather than a proven hit.
The Top 10 at a Glance
| # | Production | Type | Critic Score | Reviews | Audience | Theatre | Run Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hamilton | Musical | 91 | 45 | A+ | Richard Rodgers Theatre | Open-ended |
| 2 | The Book of Mormon | Musical | 89 | 32 | A- | Eugene O’Neill Theatre | Open-ended |
| 3 | Oh, Mary! | Play | 88 | 34 | A | Lyceum Theatre | On sale to Jan 3, 2027 |
| 4 | Downstate | Play | 87 | 25 | A | Booth Theatre | Feb 14, 2027 |
| 5 | The Lion King | Musical | 87 | 25 | A | Minskoff Theatre | Open-ended |
| 6 | Chicago | Musical | 86 | 10 | B+ | Ambassador Theatre | Open-ended |
| 7 | Maybe Happy Ending | Musical | 85 | 42 | A+ | Belasco Theatre | Open-ended |
| 8 | Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | Play | 85 | 71 | A- | Lyric Theatre | Open-ended |
| 9 | Hadestown | Musical | 83 | 51 | A+ | Walter Kerr Theatre | Open-ended |
| 10 | It's A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play | Play | TBD | 1 | B+ | Broadhurst Theatre | Jan 3, 2027 |
Source: Broadway Scorecard, “Top 10 Highest Rated Broadway Shows (2026),” November 2026. Theatres and run status from theatre, ticketing and press listings. Scores will change as reviews arrive.
1. Hamilton
Score: 91 (Critical Gold) · 45 reviews · Audience A+ · Richard Rodgers Theatre, 226 West 46th Street
Lin-Manuel Miranda’s hip-hop history of Alexander Hamilton opened at the Richard Rodgers Theatre on August 6, 2015, and IBDB had counted 3,877 performances by June 7, 2026. Eleven Tony Awards, a Pulitzer Prize for Drama and a Grammy for the cast album are its credentials, and the box office suggests they have not dulled. For the week ending November 8, Hamilton grossed $2,697,304 at 100.40% of capacity, with an average ticket of $253.65, which made it the highest-grossing show on Broadway. BroadwayWorld listed it at 100.49% capacity in early July, and the same outlet’s weekly report on September 8 was headlined “Hamilton Claims Top Spot.”
The cast has kept turning over. IBDB lists several 2026 changes in the principal company, with new faces in the title role and as Angelica and Eliza from May 12. The show also welcomed back an original member of the company: Christopher Jackson, who earned a Tony nomination for George Washington, returned to the role for a strictly limited engagement from September 8. The musical continues in London’s West End, where Leslie Odom, Jr. was announced for a limited summer engagement and tickets are on sale through March 13, 2027.
The score rests mostly on 2015 reviews, but the A+ audience grade shows people still rate it as highly as the critics once did. One 2026 analysis argued that the filmed version has made the live show feel more personal, because audiences arrive already attached to the story.
2. The Book of Mormon
Score: 89 (Critical Gold) · 32 reviews · Audience A- · Eugene O’Neill Theatre, 230 West 49th Street
Trey Parker, Matt Stone and Robert Lopez’s musical comedy about two young missionaries in Uganda won nine Tony Awards in 2011, including Best Musical. It is the longest-running show in the Eugene O’Neill’s 100-year history and, per Playbill and TheaterMania, the tenth-longest-running musical in Broadway history. The show hit 15 years in March, and the milestone was marked all year.
The anniversary celebrations were the story of its spring and summer. A “Magical Mormon Mystery Week” of performances on June 9–14 featured original stars Andrew Rannells (Elder Price), Josh Gad (Elder Cunningham), Nikki M. James (Nabulungi) and Rory O’Malley (Elder McKinley), and the original cast reunited at the 79th Tony Awards at Radio City Music Hall on June 7. A fire damaged parts of the Eugene O’Neill on May 4, canceling performances for three weeks until the show resumed on May 27, which makes the reunion all the more notable.
The reunion is still going. Nikki M. James, who won a Tony for Nabulungi, and Rory O’Malley, who was nominated for Elder McKinley, returned on October 27 for a 12-week engagement through January 17, 2027. The AP noted it had been 12 years since James last played the role on Broadway. For the week ending November 8 the show grossed $867,177, and the A- audience grade from 32 reviews confirms that the show is still a comedy people trust.
3. Oh, Mary!
Score: 88 (Critical Gold) · 34 reviews · Audience A · Lyceum Theatre, 149 West 45th Street
Cole Escola’s Oh, Mary! is the highest-ranked play on the list and the newest of the top three. Tony-winning star and writer Escola created this irreverent riff on Mary Todd Lincoln in the weeks before the assassination, and director Sam Pinkleton also won a Tony. The show opened at the Lyceum on July 11, 2024, and was the first production in the theatre’s 121-year history to gross more than $1 million in a single week. It runs 80 minutes with no intermission and is recommended for ages 14 and up.
The title role has become a revolving door of famous names. Jane Krakowski gave her final performance on January 4, 2026, and Escola played an encore run from April 8 to June 21 alongside original cast members Conrad Ricamora and James Scully. Maya Rudolph made her Broadway debut from April 28, with Cheyenne Jackson, Phillip James Brannon and Bianca Leigh returning, and Bowen Yang, the Saturday Night Live favourite, made his Broadway acting debut on September 15 for 12 weeks through December 6. Reviews gathered by BroadwayWorld included 10-out-of-10 notices, and the show broke its own box-office record in the week ending May 3. Its gross for the week ending November 8 was $1,439,647, with an average ticket of $208.86. A West End production and a North American tour run alongside it.
4. Downstate
Score: 87 (Critical Gold) · 25 reviews · Audience A · Booth Theatre, 222 West 45th Street
The newest serious drama on Broadway is also the most provocative. Bruce Norris’s Downstate is set in a group home for convicted sex offenders, and its Broadway production opened on November 15 at the Booth Theatre after previews that began on October 22. Directed by Joe Mantello, it stars Cassie Beck, K. Todd Freeman, Francis Guinan, Adrian Martinez, Al’Jaleel McGhee, Thomas Sadoski, Ivy Wolk and Emmy winner Liza Colón-Zayas. Norris, a Pulitzer Prize and Tony winner, premiered the play at Steppenwolf in Chicago in 2018; it then played the National Theatre in London and Playwrights Horizons off-Broadway in 2022, and won the New York Drama Critics’ Circle Award for Best Play.
Reviews were strong. BroadwayWorld’s tracker counted 12 positive reviews and one mixed with none negative, including notices from The New York Times (Helen Shaw), Time Out New York and New York Theatre. TheaterMania headlined its review “the most dangerous play on Broadway,” and TheWrap argued that the unlikely subject matter proves exactly why the play belongs on Broadway. The show is for audiences 17 and over.
The play was announced as a strictly limited 12-week engagement that would close on January 10, 2027. After its first extension it now runs through February 14, 2027. It grossed $348,713 in eight previews the week ending November 8, at 97.66% of capacity.
5. The Lion King
Score: 87 (Critical Gold) · 25 reviews · Audience A · Minskoff Theatre, 200 West 45th Street
Julie Taymor’s staging of Disney’s The Lion King opened at the Minskoff on November 13, 1997, and has just entered its 29th year. Only two shows have run longer on Broadway: The Phantom of the Opera and Chicago. It passed 10,000 performances in May 2023 and reached its 11,000th on September 20, 2025. It also made composer Lebo M and choreographer Garth Fagan the longest-running Black composer and choreographer in Broadway history.
Its consistency is remarkable. TheaterMania reported in 2024 that the musical had been in the top five grossing Broadway shows virtually every week of its run, and for the week ending November 8 it earned $1,803,837, second only to Hamilton. Playbill has reported that it has been seen by 115 million people across its productions worldwide. Most of the reviews counted by Broadway Scorecard are from 1997, but the A audience grade shows that no matter how old the notices, audiences are still giving it the thumbs-up.
6. Chicago
Score: 86 (Critical Gold) · 10 reviews · Audience B+ · Ambassador Theatre, 219 West 49th Street
Chicago has the smallest critic sample among the nine scored shows, just ten reviews, but its position in Broadway history is secure. The revival opened at the Richard Rodgers Theatre on November 14, 1996, moved to the Shubert, and has played the Ambassador since January 29, 2003. Playbill calls it the second-longest-running show in Broadway history, after The Phantom of the Opera, and the Shubert Organization calls it the longest-running American musical. It won six Tony Awards in 1997, including Best Revival of a Musical, and has been seen by 33 million people in 36 countries. It marked 30 years on Broadway on November 14.
Star casting has been the engine of the 2026 box office. Whitney Leavitt of Hulu’s The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives made her Broadway debut as Roxie Hart on February 2 and returned for a run through May 3, which included a spell opposite Dancing with the Stars’ Mark Ballas as Billy Flynn from April 6. Krysta Rodriguez took over as Roxie on June 15, comedian Matteo Lane made his Broadway debut as Billy on June 22, Eddie Cooper joined as Amos on July 20, and Lissa deGuzman became Velma on August 31. The grosses for the week ending November 8 were $942,448.
7. Maybe Happy Ending
Score: 85 (Critical Gold) · 42 reviews · Audience A+ · Belasco Theatre, 111 West 44th Street
Will Aronson and Hue Park’s musical about two obsolete helper robots in Seoul is the youngest of the Tony-winning musicals on this list. It opened on November 12, 2024, won the Tony for Best Musical in 2025 and was named the best theatre of 2024 by The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and New York magazine. It is directed by Michael Arden. Playbill reports it has become the longest-running show in the history of the Belasco Theatre.
The year’s cast story is the passing of the torch from original stars. Helen J Shen played her final performance as Claire on February 15, and Darren Criss left on May 17. Zachary Noah Piser now plays Oliver opposite Hannah Kevitt as Claire, with original cast members Dez Duron and Marcus Choi continuing. TheaterMania reviewed the new company in July under the headline “A Reminder That Broadway Can Be Great.” A national tour began in Baltimore in September, led by Steven Huynh and Claire Kwon, and the Broadway production grossed $736,268 in the week ending November 8. Its A+ audience grade is shared with Hamilton and Hadestown, the best on the list.
8. Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Score: 85 (Critical Gold) · 71 reviews · Audience A- · Lyric Theatre, 214 West 43rd Street
Based on an original story by J.K. Rowling, Jack Thorne and John Tiffany, with a script by Thorne and direction by Tiffany, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child has played the Lyric since April 2018 and is now the third-longest-running non-musical play in Broadway history. It has the biggest critic sample of any show on the list, 71 reviews, which makes its 85 one of the most robust scores in the top ten.
The big 2026 story is Tom Felton. The actor who played Draco Malfoy in all eight Harry Potter films made his Broadway debut in the role on November 11, 2025, the first member of the film cast to join the stage production. He was initially booked for 19 weeks, then extended to May 10, then to November 1, and now to January 3, 2027. Playbill and BroadwayWorld reported in April that the show had held the number-one spot on the Broadway grosses since his arrival. The cast also features John Skelley as Harry Potter, Trish Lindstrom as Ginny and Emmet Smith as Albus. For the week ending November 8, the production grossed $1,673,022, third highest on Broadway.
9. Hadestown
Score: 83 (Critical Gold) · 51 reviews · Audience A+ · Walter Kerr Theatre, 219 West 48th Street
Anaïs Mitchell’s folk opera, directed by Rachel Chavkin, began Broadway performances in March 2019 and won eight Tony Awards including Best Musical. It has been at the Walter Kerr for seven years, and this year it has been reinvented twice through casting. On March 3, an all-new principal cast arrived: Joshua Colley as Orpheus, Jordan Tyson as Eurydice, Tony winner J. Harrison Ghee as Hermes, Grammy winner Gaby Moreno as Persephone and Gary Dourdan as Hades. John-Michael Lyles took over as Orpheus on June 16, and original cast member Jewelle Blackman rejoined as one of the Fates in April.
A second wave began on September 1, with Norbert Leo Butz, Tony nominee Amber Iman as Persephone, Jasmin Savoy Brown and Kayko, in his Broadway debut as Orpheus, joining the company. The casting was not without drama: Geno Segers, announced as Hades, withdrew in early August, and Tony honoree Ben Davis was named in his place. TheaterMania also reports that a film of the London company recently overtook Hamilton for the biggest opening weekend by a professionally shot stage production. It grossed $927,897 in the week ending November 8.
10. It’s A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play
Score: Not yet rated · 1 review · Audience B+ · Broadhurst Theatre, 235 West 44th Street · Through January 3, 2027
Joe Landry’s 1996 adaptation of the Frank Capra film, a regional-theatre staple, makes its Broadway debut this holiday season. Directed by four-time Tony winner Jerry Zaks, the production presents the story of George Bailey as a 1940s radio broadcast on Christmas Eve, complete with a live foley artist and holiday carols. Andrew Rannells plays George opposite Megan Hilty as Mary Bailey, with Tituss Burgess as Clarence, Harry Hamlin as Mr. Potter and Lisa Rinna as Violet; each actor plays multiple roles. Santo Loquasto designed the sets and costumes, and the play runs about 90 minutes without an intermission.
Previews began on November 4, and the show opened on November 18, so the critical verdict is still arriving. Broadway Scorecard had only one review at the time of writing and lists the show as not yet rated, with an audience grade of B+. In its six preview performances the week ending November 8, it grossed $322,788 at 77.93% capacity. If you are planning a holiday outing, the engagement is limited to nine weeks, closing January 3, 2027, and Broadway.com is advertising it as a holiday comfort show.
Box Office: How the Top 10 Are Selling
Critical acclaim is one thing, but the weekly grosses show what audiences are actually buying. The table below sets out each show’s gross for the week ending November 8.
| Production | Week ending Nov 8 gross | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Hamilton | $2,697,304 | 100.40% of capacity; average ticket $253.65 |
| The Lion King | $1,803,837 | Minskoff Theatre |
| Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | $1,673,022 | Lyric Theatre |
| Oh, Mary! | $1,439,647 | Average ticket $208.86 |
| Chicago | $942,448 | Ambassador Theatre |
| Hadestown | $927,897 | Walter Kerr Theatre |
| The Book of Mormon | $867,177 | Eugene O’Neill Theatre |
| Maybe Happy Ending | $736,268 | Belasco Theatre |
| Downstate | $348,713 | Eight previews, 97.66% capacity |
| It’s A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play | $322,788 | Six previews, 77.93% capacity |
Source: Broadway League weekly grosses as reported by BroadwayWorld and IBDB, week ending November 8, 2026. Previews for Downstate and It’s A Wonderful Life reflect partial weeks.
Hamilton grossed nearly $900,000 more than the second-place show, The Lion King. Harry Potter and Oh, Mary!, both built around celebrity casting this year, follow. Downstate, a challenging play about a difficult subject, took nearly $350,000 in eight previews, a promising start for a limited engagement.
What the 2026 Rankings Tell Us
Look across the list and several things stand out. Four of the ten opened more than a decade ago, and only two (Downstate and It’s A Wonderful Life) opened in the 2026–27 season. That longevity is not an accident. Many of these shows have used casting to keep audiences coming back: original stars returning to The Book of Mormon, Hollywood names in Chicago and Oh, Mary!, a film actor in Harry Potter, a reunion of Fates at Hadestown. Even Hamilton brought back Christopher Jackson.
It is not a complete picture of 2026. Playbill reported record box office at Cats: The Jellicle Ball before its August 8 closing, and BroadwayWorld reported records for Ragtime and The Whoopi Monologues in the week ending August 2. This guide covers shows currently running and ranked by Broadway Scorecard.
When to See Them: A Booking Guide
| Production | What to know | Date |
|---|---|---|
| It’s A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play | Limited holiday run, Broadhurst Theatre | Through Sunday, Jan 3, 2027 |
| Harry Potter and the Cursed Child | Tom Felton’s extended engagement as Draco Malfoy | Felton through Jan 3, 2027 |
| Oh, Mary! | Bowen Yang as Mary Todd Lincoln | Yang through Dec 6; tickets listed to Jan 3, 2027 |
| The Book of Mormon | Nikki M. James and Rory O’Malley return | Through Jan 17, 2027 |
| Downstate | Limited engagement, extended once | Through Feb 14, 2027 |
| Hamilton, Lion King, Chicago, Maybe Happy Ending, Hadestown | No closing date announced | Open-ended |
Dates as reported by the productions and listing sites at the time of writing; extensions and cast changes are common.
If you only have time for one, the answer depends on who you are. Families and first-timers should start with The Lion King. Comedy lovers should aim for Oh, Mary! before Bowen Yang’s run ends on December 6, or The Book of Mormon while Nikki M. James and Rory O’Malley are on stage. Fans of serious drama should book Downstate soon, since it is a limited engagement. Harry Potter fans should see Tom Felton before January 3, and anyone in the mood for something festive has a limited window for It’s A Wonderful Life.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the highest-rated Broadway show of 2026?
Hamilton leads Broadway Scorecard’s highest-rated list with a critic score of 91 out of 100 from 45 reviews. The Book of Mormon is second at 89 and Oh, Mary! third at 88. Hamilton’s and The Book of Mormon’s scores rest largely on reviews from their original openings.
How does Broadway Scorecard calculate its critic score?
It is a weighted average of professional reviews, with outlets such as The New York Times, Vulture and Variety counting for more. Audience letter grades are shown separately.
Which top Broadway shows have a closing date?
Downstate is booking through February 14, 2027 after its first extension, and It’s A Wonderful Life: A Live Radio Play closes January 3, 2027. Tom Felton’s run in Harry Potter and the Cursed Child and Nikki M. James and Rory O’Malley’s return to The Book of Mormon (to January 17, 2027) are limited engagements within open-ended productions.
Why does It’s A Wonderful Life have no score?
The show opened on November 18, 2026 and Broadway Scorecard had counted only one review at the time of writing. The site lists it as not yet rated until more critics weigh in.
Which show is the best for a first visit to Broadway?
Our pick for families and first-timers is The Lion King, with Hamilton and Hadestown as strong choices for musical-lovers. All three hold audience grades of A or better on Broadway Scorecard.
Sources
Broadway Scorecard, Top 10 Highest Rated Broadway Shows (2026); plus Playbill, TheaterMania, BroadwayWorld, Broadway.com, Broadway News, New York Theatre Guide, IBDB, TDF, TheWrap, the Walt Disney Company and the productions’ own announcements.
| #Broadway #Top10Broadway #Hamilton #BookOfMormon #OhMary #Downstate #LionKing #ChicagoMusical #MaybeHappyEnding #HarryPotterCursedChild #Hadestown #Theatregold |
Data note: Scores, review counts and audience grades are from Broadway Scorecard as of November 2026 and will change as new reviews arrive. Box office figures are for the week ending November 8, 2026. Venues, casts and dates come from press and ticketing listings, which sometimes disagree. This article describes critical reception in our own words and does not reproduce reviews.